News

Horizontal is Creative, Vertical is not

by Bruce DeBoer
Saturday, May 27, 2006. 02:33PM
Technorati Tags:
663 Views 4 Comments

I know you’ve had this experience:

You’re hanging at a party and a friend introduces you to a fellow expert. “Hey Bruce, Joe Bob does creative marketing stuff.” Cornered for what seems like an hour, with no gracious exit, I listen as if interested while Joe Bob drones endlessly about the detailed minutia of his Medical Pipette business. Can I offer marketing suggestions? No, Joe Bob insists he’s got a good creative handle on pipette marketing. "You don't understand our market" Hence, my role in this conversation was listen and nod.

You can be sure if the JB Medical Pipette account goes up for review, only agencies with a strong vertical in Pipette’s will be considered. Understandable. Comfortable. Predictable.

In the creative biz, Vertical experience is helpful but broad experience is critical. Vertical knowledge is assimilated,relatively fast, horizontal knowledge takes a lifetime. Without the open mind of a landscape thinker, companies are doomed to repeat what’s been done with little variation; your silo gets taller until it falls.

(login to vote or comment.)
Thursday, August 17, 2006. 02:59PM by Bruce DeBoer
Fear is debilitating isn't it? So many who take risks get rewarded that it's a wonder why more don't figure out that success selling burgers can translate to floor polish.
Thursday, August 17, 2006. 09:05AM by Jeremy Feldman
I know. I got pegged as a "tech writer" at one agency when I was freelancing a few years ago. So for months they wouldn't bring me on because their tech accounts weren't active. Then, once I got there, I pitched in one week writing some emails. Suddenly I was an "interactive" writer and they would only give me interactive projects on tech accounts. The irony is that agencies and clients keep asking for "out of the box" thinking, but they're way too scared to hire people with "out of the box" experience.
Thursday, August 17, 2006. 08:39AM by Charlie Henss
Agencies, all too often, are just as bad as clients in this regard. How many times have you seen a "help wanted" ad that requested experience in a specific product category? Are the lessons learned in pharmaceuticals truly useless in packaged goods, and vice versa? I doubt it, but the world seems to think otherwise.
Wednesday, June 7, 2006. 07:06AM by Jeremy Feldman
See, usually I'm in the position of trying to explain what I do in the first place. I usually say that I'm a writer and I work in advertising. But not everyone gets that. I was at a dinner a few years ago with an old high school friend who has his PhD from MIT in economics. He really didn't understand how someone could get paid to do what I do. Another time, at a wedding for a friend of mine who works in high finance, I made the mistake of telling someone that I was a copywriter. This caused all sorts of confusion, because she was sure I worked in copywrite law.