News

Think Broken.

by Marc Lefton
Monday, December 12, 2005. 06:04PM
1,088 Views 9 Comments

I've owned Apple products since 1991, and used them since 1988. Since I'm what some would consider an advanced user, I've solved all problems myself, 99% which were software related. (My monitor card got loose once.)

But no more. Not since I bought a new iBook G4 in May. About two months ago, the computer wouldn't start. Nothing happened when I hit the power button. So, trying everything I knew without results, I brought it to the Apple Genius bar at their store in SoHo. There, the technician told me the logic board needed to be reset. "Apple-option-control-shift-power, hold for 5 seconds, wait 5 seconds, then hit power." Miraculously, it booted up again. An entire night tossing and turning, thinking about possibly losing information, having to pay for costly repairs, and being out my computer were resolved quickly. I had budgeted the entire morning for this–now I can go get breakfast. "Oh, you might need to eventually get that logic board replaced" he foreshadowed.

Sure enough, two weeks ago tomorrow, upon returning home to my loft in the East Williamsburg Industrial Park from Adholes World Headquarters in the East Village, a 20 minute trek on the L train that should not have made my laptop randomly turn off en route, the laptop would not start again. "Aha, all I need is the magic Apple-option-control-shift-power trick." I did it, and sure enough, the "ding" of the computer starting up happened. It booted up fine. I got to my messy desktop. I went to open my mail. And the screen went black.

I rebooted, did the Apple-option-control-shift-power trick again. And nothing. And then strange things happened. The screen would flash between solid colors. The hard drive would go WHIIIRRRRRRRR. The fan was on so fast that you could feel a rush of air out of the back.

The next day, I went to the on-site freelance job I thankfully had (how else was I going to get emails from an associate trying to micromanage my efforts?) and did some searching. Sure enough, the logic board was kaput.

But further digging led me to find some alarming statistics. That this has been a problem dating back to a design flaw in the G3 series of iBooks. And that THIRTEEN PERCENT of laptops are failing. In fact, my neighbor two cubes down who owns a little ad agency just had the same thing happen to his.

Now, it's one thing for a thirteen percent failure rate to occur. It's another to be lame about fixing it quickly. Unless you pay for their AppleCare Extortion Program, you get treated like cattle.

My first experience with this was making another appointment that evening at the Genius Bar, for the 7-7:30 time slot. I was sitting next to another guy, who was there right before me. So I figured when he went, I was next. 8:30 rolls around, and we're still not taken. Together, we decide to ask what's going on. "Oh, you guys didn't check in." CHECK IN? We were in the store, setting up an appointment, but they don't tell you to take the extra step of letting them know that you're there, when you already are there to make the appointment in the first place. Maybe the laptops are so faulty they cause people to spontaneously combust.

Anyway, they say, yes, indeed, it is a logic board failure. And thankfully, I am under warranty. I figure I'll just come back the next day and pick it up. After all, Apple is known for its customer service. The thing may have broken, but this is a common problem. They probably have a whole room full of logic boards.

Wrong. "It should be back in three to ten days." Says the Genius Girl. "TEN DAYS???" "Well, that's if the part isn't in stock. It should be. Hopefully it will be more like three."

Keeping up their ass, so to speak, almost every day, I found out that they didn't even bother to send the laptop to their Memphis facility via the DHL tracking number they gave me for three days. Upon its arrival, another call to them informed me that it would be "Five to seven more days." That was last Monday, now almost a week after I dropped it off. "We'll call you when it's done." They said.

Finally today, eight days after that last call, they did not call me. I called them. After entering my ever-changing repair number (they issue a new one for each thing they do to the laptop), the recorded voice said "You computer is ready to be picked up." Gee, thanks for calling!

I get to the Genius Bar, this time going right to their conscierge. "I'll see if we can find it." He says. I see them pick up my laptop and place it on the table and I wait for a guy to finish helping a customer with a broken iPod, another Apple product that's breaking records in being broken.

Finally, after 45 minutes of waiting, and then paperwork, I got my laptop back. Forty five minutes, plus fourteen days without my computer. A forced two week vacation, right before my real one, which begins tomorrow. Just what I needed. Sure, I got some work done. I borrowed an old iMac from my friend's wife. But it's not the same. It's still not the same, because I'm not done transferring all the emails I need from the other computer. Life is still out of sorts. Thanks Apple!

Is Apple still a Lovemark™ for me? I think not. Sure, we'll stay together for the sake of the kids. But this is a loveless marriage from here on out. Heck, I might even see a Dell or an HP on the side--to fulfill some of my...gaming needs. For what I paid for the laptop, I could have had a room full of Dells. And for what I paid for it, I deserved better service, faster service, and at the very least, not having to schlep in my friend's Jeep to Manhattan Mini Storage to get a loaner computer.

Shame on you, Apple! You're just another big corporate bully putting profits ahead of people.

(login to vote or comment.)
Tuesday, March 28, 2006. 12:08PM by Jesse Tayler
I've had very good luck with Apple hardware, but a week or two ago, my mother's computer (iMac G4) started to smell like it was burning -- BAD -- while watching a DVD. Rightly so, she turned it off and called Apple who invited her to bring it right into the store. Great, but the entire machine was basically fried, they did not really make any effort to keep her personal account files, just left them on a newly formatted disk with a single, default user. Every application, printer driver, and user account needed to be rebuilt and re-installed. She was never able to re-create her iTunes library at all! The computer was given to her in a way that for my mom, or any mortal human being, would be basically impossible to use! They gave her her the machine without saying a word. When she plugged it in, there was no hope for her to return the system to a useable state.

To their credit, Apple did let a `Genius' help for several hours to rebuild where possible, but not saving her applications or drivers still meant some long hours of frustration to get the computer to work. Bummer on that....

Thursday, January 19, 2006. 05:35PM by Marc Lefton
Yeah Deborah--you're lucky you're not like my friends who decided they'd stop wasting hard drive space and deleted their MP3s once they were on the iPod. I have like 3 friends who lost their entire music collections. And I'm sure these new Intel Processors...well, they're cheaper.
Wednesday, January 18, 2006. 01:06PM by
Someone bought me an iPod for Christmas and it lasted all of a WEEK before breaking. Apple has been good about it, they are sending me a new one in the mail but it's gone AWOL so now they are tracking it. This is the second problem I've had in less than a year in regards to faulty MAC products. My love affair with the company is slowly dying... :(
Wednesday, January 18, 2006. 12:57PM by Bonnie Natko
Add another logic board mishap to the list - one of my cowokers just had the same problem....and today I get an email about the new MacBook Pro (you know, the one with the INTEL processor). Grrrrrr.
Wednesday, December 14, 2005. 09:44PM by Marc Lefton
Mark-not jumping ship, but rather pointing how Apple has a stellar reputation that far exceeds what they're currently offering to their customers. Do a google search for "ibook logic board" and you'll come across protest sites, and dozens of message board threads of people having this same drastic problem. It's bad enought that THIRTEEN PERCENT are failing, not to be compounded by leaving someone without a mac for two weeks when most people use them because they're freelancers. Oh yeah--what's the deal with Techserv? I was under warranty- but if I sent it there would I get faster service and then they just bill Apple instead? Or is that where you go when your warranty expires?
Wednesday, December 14, 2005. 06:42PM by
I've been having problems with the new MAC I purchased in May as well...sometimes that weird DOS screen (I don't know what the term for this is...it's the screen that is on PCs upon start-up, lots of white code on a black background) comes up. I've also been hearing a lot of complaints about iPods, which is why I'm the last person in North America to not own one.
Tuesday, December 13, 2005. 09:48AM by mike lightman
They're usually pretty good with repairs, but every once in a while they take a major dump on some unsuspecting soul. sorry to hear you got the big fruit shaft.
Tuesday, December 13, 2005. 08:08AM by Jessica Scarane
The exact same problem kept happening to my roommate's Powerbook last year - Not booting up, irresponsive power button, etc. It completely crapped out 3 times in like, 6 months. Every time, she had to do whatever that thing is called when you just turn your computer into a storage device not a compy to retreive and back up all her files and then ship it out. They'd send it back and say it was fine, but 2 - 3 months it would happen again. Finally over the summer when it happened yet again, they just totally trashed her compy and gave her the brand new one. I guess that's one up side. But the fact that it just shit out on her was ridiculous. She never takes it off her desk, has a cooling tablet that it sits on, the whole thing. Yet it still had a problem. Luckily, her new one hasn't acted up yet. Good luck with yours.
Tuesday, December 13, 2005. 07:44AM by Mark Weills
Marc- I think that I am one of the only folks on earth that have never taken any of my Apple products in for service. I have never had a single problem. I have seen the problems in my former life as a Mac tech for Chiat\Day, but even then it was minimal. I don't doubt that you take care of your laptop, but most users do not. They beat the shit out of them, then whine when they don't work. I have seen folks pour beer, coffee, whatever into their running laptop and can't figure out why it takes a shit on them. I had a user once who could not figure out why her keyboard did not work. I asked her all of the pertinent questions and still not a single clue, until I picked up the keyboard and water came pouring out of it. I do think that Apple's growth and their opening the standards a bit, to use cheaper parts, has started to degrade the quality a little. When Apple controlled the suppliers so tightly, their products were indestructable, now the lemons seems to be a little more common than they were in the past. Anyway, just a word of caution before you decide to jump ship to an equally if not more unpredictable product. I know, I had to service all of the other manufacturers shit in the past. (This is not a Mac vs. PC answer, just someone who has seen the computer business from both the enduser side and the tech side.) BTW, good luck. The upside of your problem is this, after a few times of it fucking up, they usually replace it for you. So look forward to a brand new computer. I say, try TEkserve next time. I have heard that they are a little more apt to take it to another level, as in senior tech managment level.