News

Calling out Adcritic's No Spot Festival

by Kaza Razat
Thursday, September 14, 2006. 07:01AM
771 Views 8 Comments

Adcritic & Creativity magazine hosts an annual film festival called the No Spot film festival. This is the third year for the festival which in my opinion was designed to showcase the filmmaking skills of Ad industry creatives aspiring to directorial success. Now I want to be really careful here because I entered that contest last year ($195 entry fee) and I absolutely love how Creativity magazine covers the industry. But I have to call them out on this. I looked at the line up of Directors for this year’s contest (2006) and 7 out of the 10 finalist are: Spike Jonze, Neil Blomkamp, Curious Pictures, Gwyneth Paltrow, Charlie White, Happy and Mary Wigmore. WTF? My issue is that Its hard enough for young directors to get noticed without refinancing their grandmother’s house to make an ill-advised indy film. Now the festivals originally designed for them are being taken over by professionals who certainly don’t need the publicity and can get into the elite festivals with ease. At the end of the day Its all about money to these businesses. I get that, but what they’re doing is just wrong. Tell people that professionals are allowed to enter before you take $200 dollars from them. How many young directors do they think would enter then? I dissuaded one director this year from entering because of the steep entry fee and the ‘shadyness’ of the festival and looking at that list of finalist I’m glad I did. I highly doubt Spike Jonze even paid the entry fee. They probably paid him to enter.

What does the Adholes community think about this?

The No Spot Finalist: Click to Open Web Page

(login to vote or comment.)
Wednesday, October 18, 2006. 07:40PM by Dee Archer-Allen
Thanks for the kind words. The Anonymous Content office in NYC would probably be happy to send you a copy of this his short - which I'll proudly say he wrote as well - and filmed, produced, edited, directed... a one man show, in 16mm. I'm not sure Cody had any opinion on the pros, and Spike Jonze was in inspiration of his, so I think he was pleased to be included in the same group. And I'm not sure I can say he isn't a professional - but I can say he's a young, struggling filmmaker and this was his first non-sports film. Cody has had 3 other films, 2 of which were distributed and out in stores worldwide (direct to DVD)- all snowboarding films - the first of which he made when he was 13 in digi, the second and third at 15 and 16 in 16mm. He was also nominated for Aspiring Director at the 2005 Sundance concurrent X-Dance Film Festival (all action sports) for his third snowboarding film, The Brightest Sound, at 16 years old. Anyway, proud mom will be turning this into an ad... But call Anonymous there in NYC and I'm sure they'll send you a copy of "Other Than Marcus and Adeline". Enjoying the site, though I'm VP, Sales/Marketing for a high tech company that serves the new media industry (among others) and am not in advertising.
Wednesday, October 18, 2006. 05:49PM by Kaza Razat
Very nice Dee. Tell your son congratulations. I stand corrected. I am relieved to hear that at least one amatuer was talented enough to stand out amongst the professional entries. I will try to view his piece. Incidentally what does he think of professionals having been allowed to enter the contest and festival?
Wednesday, October 18, 2006. 12:03AM by Dee Archer-Allen
For what it's worth, my 18 year old son entered his first short in this festival - produced for $2,000 - and was one of the finalists (Cody Allen). No Big Fix for at least this one entry... he has worked for the past 18 months in Anonymous Content's editing "Vault"...his first job while still in high school... Just thought I'd mention it. Stumbled on the site - Very cool, BTW. Keep up the great work!
Monday, September 25, 2006. 01:49PM by Sunil Shibad
It's another money-making racket. I think I should start one and rake in a few bucks.
Thursday, September 14, 2006. 09:11AM by Kaza Razat
They should have different categories Kim. At $195 it's one of the more expensive entry fees and the premise originally was to discover directing talent at agencies and post houses. Now they straight up have allowed "ringers" in. If they want to do that make it free. Then a person would feel even better if they win.
Thursday, September 14, 2006. 08:16AM by Kim S
As someone who used to be heavily involved in the awards process for the NorCal Emmy's, there are "categories" in place to take care of advertising agencies trying to sneak in and get an award that was in theory supposed to go to a broadcast producer / director / writer etc. In my opinion a good festival includes levels of categories whereby all entrants have equal standing in that category. For instance: dollars. Films under 50K, Films over 50K are just two examples. To be able to win an award and say there were folks like the ones mentioned above also entering the "festival" adds a level of sophistication to actually getting the statue and putting it on your mantel.
Thursday, September 14, 2006. 07:54AM by Buddy 'Friendly' Wachenheimer
The fix is in
Thursday, September 14, 2006. 07:17AM by Mark Roberts
Oh, crap. At first I mis-read and thought they were screening the entrants. Yep, that sounds like a rig job. Probably some PR firm hooked up a bunch of insiders looking for another festival to snake into.