News

Reality Check

by Noelle Weaver
Tuesday, December 28, 2004. 07:39PM
431 Views 9 Comments

On the journey home for Christmas I came across the top censored stories as reported by Utne Reader. It seems a media story was buried during the election this year, reporting that the top 1 percent of the U.S. population now owns about a third of the country’s wealth, and the highly touted American middle class is quickly disappearing. Thanks to various legislative measures that were passed last year, the division between rich and poor has been [and is] being further accelerated. Beyond political and international repercussions, I began to think about the implications this division of class has on advertisers.

I will not lie. I am, what some may call a “redneck.” I was born in a small blue collar town in America’s heartland. Most people still have four kids and live in a trailer park waiting for Friday’s paycheck in order to buy a six pack of Bud and $20 in lottery tickets. The norm is minimum wage and two jobs or 10-hours in a factory assembly line. Kids grow up on a bevy of fast food and the latest American Idol episode where anyone can be a star. Groceries are bought, not by brand loyalty but by “what’s on sale.” It’s a different reality.

In a bit of light hearted humor [and yet seriousness] …a further examination of this consumer audience shows us that:

1.Any hors d’ourve with a “fine piece of cheese” will most likely contain a slab of Velveeta on a Ritz cracker. If it is a special occasion, it will be served on a pizza pan covered with tin foil. [BTW: Don’t expect to cook anything that requires Feta, if you do… only one supermarket chain carries it and the package will have expired last month.]

2. There are people in this world who still use AOL. And LOVE it.

3. Oprah Winfrey is still the Queen of all things good. Med actually watch Dr. Phil. And Martha is not only guilty; she’s “done.”

4. Miracle Whip is not a white viscous product in a jar sold by Kraft - - but a fine flavor enhancer for your bologna sandwich. Also, Grey Poupon = expensive mustard.

5. Given the choice between a free cotton t-shirt that can be washed at home and an expensive designer Cashmere sweater that says “dry-clean,” the cotton shirt will win every time.

6. “Me Time” isn’t a bubble bath with floral accents. It isn’t curling up on a couch with a relaxing cup of chai tea [how do you say that?]. It is simply the 15 minutes of quiet time after the kids have fallen asleep from their over scheduled day when she sits down on the couch [and before she passes out in utter exhaustion.]

7. “I am on a diet” means ordering the fried chicken salad with extra ranch dressing and a Diet Coke instead of the fried chicken sandwich, fries and a Mt. Dew.

8. Masstige is a foreign word. And Target is pronounced “Tar – get” not “Tar-ghay” and it’s a place to buy cotton towels not some “fancy” clothes or “city” décor.

9. Yankee Candles. 17% sales increase for the year. Nuff said?

10. There is a segment of the American population that will join Bally’s health club yet still insist on getting in the car and driving across the strip mall parking lot instead of walking to the other end.

***************************************************************** As I was home, I got to looking at the culture around me and to thinking back to this year’s election… the strife between red and blue states…has living in New York City made us this out-of-touch with the rest of America? And if NYC is the “heart” of advertising… are we, as an industry, out of touch with the consumers we sell our client’s products to? And should we be paying more attention?

After all, these are the same folks that gave us Scrapbooking, NASCAR, Deep Fried Turkeys, and Trucker Hats.

(login to vote or comment.)
Saturday, January 1, 2005. 03:56PM by M W
I believe you read Trading Up...and it pissed you off a bit. Can't say I blame you.
Friday, December 31, 2004. 10:42AM by Jackie Herships
Funny - as prices rice in my newly rechic Newark, NJ subarb of South Orange, I've been thinking about trailor parks a lot lately. There's a nice one on the edge of NJ as you hit PA, it has summer camp sites that remind me of Girl Scout camp and year round hook-ups cost about $200 per month which includes gas and water. You can't beat that. Perhaps unintentionally, but nonethe less true, Trailor parks are to be commended for using fewer resources. Maybe Tar-get should take a crack at Trailor Park design and pull us all into the act. It would solve a lot of problems. Also, try lime jello with mayonaise and chopped cucumber, whipped, as a terrific holiday mold. Upscale vershion: add mint.
Thursday, December 30, 2004. 08:09PM by john follis
Luv it... sounds like a Jeff Foxworthy "you know you're a redneck if..." routine. And, as you suggest, any New Yorker who doesn't spend much time outside the 5 boroughs probably won't have a pulse on the America described in your posting. But don't focus groups and the multitude of other reliable research methods resolve your concern about NY centric ad folks being out-of-touch? As a sidebar, it's my understanding that the very NY-centric "Seinfeld" is one of the most popular shows with the bologna-on-white demo. So perhaps a Northeast accent with your national ad campaign isn't a bad thing.
Wednesday, December 29, 2004. 05:37AM by ed burgoyne
The map below it also shows adds where the urban areas are. It also points out an additional challenge as well, in those areas that are shown, there really is a mix of people with socio-economical backgrounds. http://www.wnyc.org/news/articles/87... is a link to another nytimes article that makes some interesting points. There are some demographics out there that do like Nascar, but have big expensive pickups, a huge house with land and some significant cash to spend. And then there's the opposite, people out there that don't have a lot of money and voted for democrats. It's a mix that's going to be more important to understand as time goes on.
Tuesday, December 28, 2004. 11:04PM by Marc Lefton
Ed-That link showing the purple country is really interesting. There seem to be more areas though that are totally red, since they have low populations that are all right wing, versus areas that are all blue. Even in New York where the state always votes Democrat, there still are large pockets of Republicans, especially in Staten Island and Long Island for us locals.

Mark--deep frying the whole turkey? does it cook in the middle?
Tuesday, December 28, 2004. 10:30PM by x x
This was fun. Noelle and Marc, I grew up hearing "Tar-GHAY" constantly in Southern Indiana. At least it was said jokingly, though...a small town's version of couture. My stepfather with whom I grew up always watches NASCAR and deep-fries turkeys. My boys use/love AOL, and I grew out of Miracle Whip and into Mayonnaise. You forgot to add all the kids who were sent to school with Hostess Cherry Pies in their lunch bag.
Tuesday, December 28, 2004. 10:05PM by ed burgoyne
Sorry, here's that link... http://www.theboxtank.com/walmartbox...
Tuesday, December 28, 2004. 10:03PM by ed burgoyne
Hmmm... I have another thought. While this election focused on tactics using labels such as red vs. blue, urban vs rural/exurban, liberal vs. conservative -- I think we need to take a real strong look at the true range of demographics that are out there. Remember that map on election night? At first glance, it's no wonder the media has made a big deal of looking at certain groups that seem to have gotten less attention. But I'd like the people viewing this weblog to take a look at this link: http://www.princeton.edu/~rvdb/JAVA/... --- I think we have all seen this map at sometime or another on the web. It makes a very good point, America is really not made up of distinct red and blue, but a heck of a lot of purple. Ever check out the breakdowns in the Claratis database? Beltway boomers, young digerati, greenbelt sports, heartlanders... ack! The diversity is scary. But, without a doubt I think that we will all be hearing more about the term "exurban" in the upcoming year. Check out an interesting blog and the link to the NYT op-ed on the book "Take a Ride to Exurbia."
Tuesday, December 28, 2004. 09:38PM by Marc Lefton
I ran into this first-hand when I moved to the Berkshires (Western Mass for those of you ad people who don't make enough money to have a second home up there yet.) Girls my age (30 or less) had already had a few kids, perhaps were even on their second husband if they had even bothered to get married in the first place. Everyone smoked. Everyone had ridiculous tattoos and piercings because there really wasn't much else to do but make babies and modify your body. And either you had a bogus prescription for Oxycontin, and were selling it, or you were addicted to it, or both.

I remember concepting ads early in my career and just about every campaign we'd work on, me or someone else would have a commercial that went "So and so gets on the subway..." or "We'll do some transit ads..." And in other parts of the country I see ads with subway scenarios all the time when in fact, most people never ever take the subway or likely understand the concept of it.

Noelle, if you ever ever say "Tar-ghay" I'm going to throw my drink on you!

Anyhow, what can we on this site do to make sure we're controlling all the wealth?